this isn’t just boomerhumor, you missed something

  • stickyprimer@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    11 hours ago

    aphantasia - the inability to voluntarily create mental images in your mind’s eye.

    I guess this extends to reading? I wasn’t sure if that would count as “voluntarily” since it just seems to happen for me.

    I read to my kids every night and if there is a movie of the book we’re reading, I will finish the book with them before we watch the movie. In this way, the images they have in their minds as we read are theirs. Sometimes interesting things happen in your mind when it needs to create its own images and I think this is a personal part of reading that makes it more than just consumption but also a creative act unto itself.

    Once Hollywood has made Jennifer Lawrence the protagonist, that’s all you’ll be able to see ever again.

    However none of this would apply in your case so read or watch or listen however works best for you. Personally I find audiobooks a terrible way to read. My mind wanders instead of focusing more on the text. I realize I’ve been thinking about someone else for several minutes, and ultimately don’t retain as much from the book in the end. It’s like “having the tv on in the background” while doing household chores. That’s fine for stuff I don’t really care about, if I just want to relax and divert my mind. But if I really want to enjoy the book and get everything I can from it, I need to read it.

    Brains are obviously different. You can listen and think at the same time. I can read aloud to my kids while thinking of what I need to do at work tomorrow. However if someone is talking to me there is no way I can think about anything except the words coming out of their mouth. This is so much the case that if a person talks haltingly or takes a long time coming to the point, it physically hurts me because my brain is locked on them but they aren’t using it efficiently.

    • Sludgeyy@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      9 hours ago

      Yes it extends to reading.

      I do not have an image in my head of what Harry Potter is supposed to look like after reading the book. As long as the character in the movie didn’t have completely wrong details I wouldn’t think anything of it.

      I’m the opposite. I will read a paragraph and then realize that I was thinking about something else and even though I read the paragraph I didn’t absorb any of the knowledge.

      I couldn’t imagine reading outloud and thinking about what I need to do for work tomorrow. I have to 100% focus on reading words.

        • Sludgeyy@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          4 hours ago

          I don’t normally dream

          But when I do they are very vivid like it feels real

          I cannot determine if I am actually seeing visuals in them because after I wake up I cannot recall the images, but I feel like I can remember some details I saw visually rather than just making up the details.